Peer Review Process
Philosophy and Realistic Reflection (PRR) is committed to maintaining high standards of academic quality, integrity, and transparency through a rigorous and impartial peer review process. All manuscripts submitted to the journal must comply with its Aims and Scope and Author Guidelines. Manuscripts should demonstrate appropriate academic merit, originality, and relevance to the field of linguistic studies.
1. Initial Editorial Assessment
Upon submission, each manuscript undergoes an initial assessment by the editorial team to determine whether it:
- Falls within the Aims and Scope of the journal;
- Meets the journal's submission and formatting requirements;
- Demonstrates sufficient academic quality, originality, and relevance;
- Complies with applicable research and publication ethics standards.
The editorial team also screens submitted manuscripts using iThenticate to identify potential plagiarism and inappropriate textual overlap.
Manuscripts that fall outside the journal's scope, fail to meet its basic academic or submission requirements, or raise significant ethical concerns may be rejected without external peer review.
2. Double-Blind Peer Review
Manuscripts that pass the initial editorial assessment are subject to a double-blind peer review process. Under this system, the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from each other throughout the review process.
Each research manuscript is evaluated by at least two independent external reviewers with relevant expertise in the subject area. Reviewers are selected based on their academic qualifications, research experience, and ability to provide an objective and informed assessment.
Reviewers are asked to assess manuscripts based on the following criteria:
- Originality and significance of the research;
- Relevance to the journal's Aims and Scope;
- Adequacy of the theoretical framework and literature review;
- Soundness and appropriateness of the research methodology;
- Accuracy and reliability of the findings and interpretations;
- Clarity of presentation, academic writing, and overall scholarly contribution.
Reviewers are expected to provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based comments to help authors improve the quality of their manuscripts.
3. Reviewer Independence and Confidentiality
Reviewers must disclose any actual or potential conflicts of interest before accepting a review assignment. Individuals whose relationships or interests could compromise the impartiality of their assessment must decline the review invitation.
Editors are responsible for selecting qualified and independent reviewers and ensuring that manuscripts are evaluated fairly and consistently.
All manuscripts and related review materials must be treated as confidential. Reviewers must not disclose, distribute, or use unpublished manuscript content for personal or professional advantage. Manuscripts must not be shared with third parties without prior authorization from the journal.
The journal ensures that editorial and peer review decisions are based on academic merit and are not influenced by authors' nationality, institutional affiliation, gender, or other personal characteristics unrelated to the scholarly quality of the work.
4. Editorial Decisions
After receiving the reviewers' reports, the handling editor evaluates the comments and recommendations and makes a recommendation to the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor.
The final publication decision is made by the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor acting on behalf of the Editorial Board. Decisions are based on the reviewers' assessments, the manuscript's academic quality, its relevance to the journal's scope, and compliance with publication ethics standards.
The journal applies the following decision categories:
- Accept: The manuscript is accepted for publication in its current form, subject to any necessary editorial and production adjustments.
- Minor Revision: The manuscript requires limited revisions to address the reviewers' comments. The revised manuscript is normally assessed by the handling editor to verify that the requested changes have been adequately addressed. Further external review may be arranged if necessary.
- Major Revision: Substantial revisions are required before the manuscript can be considered further. Authors must provide a point-by-point response to the reviewers' comments. The revised manuscript will normally be returned to the original reviewers or sent to additional reviewers for further evaluation. A major revision decision does not guarantee acceptance.
- Reject: The manuscript is not considered suitable for publication in the journal. Rejected manuscripts will not be reconsidered under the same submission record. A substantially revised manuscript may be submitted as a new submission where appropriate, but it will undergo a new editorial assessment and is not guaranteed acceptance.
5. Revision and Resubmission
Authors receiving a revision decision are normally expected to submit their revised manuscripts within one to two weeks of receiving the editorial decision, unless otherwise specified by the editor.
Authors must provide:
- A revised manuscript with all changes clearly highlighted or tracked;
- A point-by-point response explaining how each reviewer and editor comment has been addressed.
If additional time is required, authors should contact the editorial office before the revision deadline to request an extension and provide a brief explanation.
If the revised manuscript is not received within the specified period and no extension has been requested or approved, the editorial office may close the submission. Authors will be notified accordingly. Any subsequent submission will be treated as a new submission and subject to a fresh editorial assessment.
6. Peer Review Timeline
The journal aims to complete the initial peer review process within approximately 2-4 weeks, depending on reviewer availability, manuscript complexity, and the time required to obtain sufficient independent assessments.
The overall time to an editorial decision may vary depending on the number of review rounds and the extent of revisions required.
The editorial office monitors the progress of submissions and follows up with reviewers when necessary to minimize avoidable delays.
7. Final Publication Decision
The final decision on publication rests with the Editor-in-Chief or an authorized editor. Reviewers provide independent academic assessments and recommendations, but their recommendations are not binding.
A positive recommendation from reviewers does not automatically guarantee acceptance. The journal reserves the right to decline publication if significant academic, ethical, or editorial concerns remain unresolved.
