Publication Ethics
- Authorship and Contributorship
- Originality, Plagiarism, and Redundant Publication
- Research Ethics and Informed Consent
- Data Availability and Research Transparency
- Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
- Responsibilities of Reviewers
- Research Misconduct and Allegations
- Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern
- Copyright, Permissions, and Third-Party Materials
- Confidentiality and Personal Information
- Publisher Responsibilities and Editorial Independence
Philosophy and Realistic Reflection is committed to maintaining high standards of publication ethics and research integrity. The journal expects authors, editors, reviewers, and the publisher to uphold the principles of honesty, transparency, fairness, accountability, and academic responsibility throughout the publication process. These principles apply to all manuscripts submitted to the journal.
The journal follows the principles and recommendations of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE). The journal also draws on relevant guidance from the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE), and the World Association of Medical Editors (WAME), where applicable to its editorial and publishing practices.
Responsibilities of Authors
Authors submitting manuscripts to Philosophy and Realistic Reflection are responsible for the originality, accuracy, integrity, and ethical compliance of their work.
Authors are expected to:
- Submit original work that has not been published previously and is not under consideration by another journal.
- Present research methods, data, findings, and interpretations accurately and honestly.
- Provide appropriate citations and acknowledgments for the ideas, methods, data, and materials of others.
- Avoid plagiarism, self-plagiarism, data fabrication, data falsification, duplicate publication, and other forms of research misconduct.
- Ensure that all listed authors have made genuine scholarly contributions and have approved the final manuscript.
- Disclose funding sources, financial support, and relevant conflicts of interest.
- Obtain appropriate ethical approval, informed consent, and permissions where required.
- Respect the privacy, rights, cultural sensitivities, and interests of research participants and linguistic communities.
- Provide accurate information about data sources, research materials, analytical procedures, and the use of AI tools.
- Cooperate with editorial inquiries and provide supporting information when reasonably requested.
Authors remain accountable for all aspects of their submitted and published work, including any material prepared with the assistance of third parties, software, or AI tools.
Authorship and Contributorship
Authorship must reflect substantial intellectual or scholarly contributions to the research and manuscript. Individuals who have contributed substantially to the conception or design of the study, data collection, analysis or interpretation, or the drafting and critical revision of the manuscript may qualify for authorship, provided that they have approved the final version and agree to be accountable for their contributions.
All listed authors must:
- Have made a meaningful contribution to the research or manuscript.
- Participate in reviewing and approving the final version.
- Agree to the submission and publication of the manuscript.
- Accept responsibility for the integrity of their contributions and cooperate in resolving questions concerning the accuracy or integrity of the work.
The corresponding author is responsible for confirming that all authors have agreed to the manuscript's submission, authorship list, and author order. The corresponding author must also ensure that all required declarations and supporting information are provided.
Individuals who have provided technical assistance, language editing, data collection support, administrative assistance, or other contributions that do not qualify for authorship should be appropriately acknowledged, with their permission.
The journal does not accept guest, gift, honorary, or ghost authorship.
Any request to add, remove, or change the order of authors after submission must be accompanied by a written explanation and confirmation from all affected authors. The journal may suspend the editorial process while the request is assessed.
The journal follows relevant COPE guidance and considers applicable ICMJE recommendations when assessing authorship and contributorship disputes.
Originality, Plagiarism, and Redundant Publication
All submissions must be original and must not have been published previously or be under consideration for publication elsewhere.
The journal does not accept:
- Plagiarism: Using another person's words, ideas, data, or work without appropriate acknowledgment.
- Self-plagiarism: Reusing substantial portions of one's previously published work without proper citation, disclosure, or justification.
- Duplicate publication: Publishing substantially the same research or findings in more than one publication without appropriate disclosure and justification.
- Data fabrication: Inventing data, participants, research materials, results, or references.
- Data falsification: Manipulating research data, procedures, or results in a misleading manner.
- Improper citation practices: Inserting irrelevant references, manipulating citation patterns, or engaging in coercive or excessive citation practices.
- Misrepresentation: Presenting the work, qualifications, research procedures, or findings inaccurately.
All submissions may undergo similarity screening and editorial assessment. Similarity reports are evaluated in context, considering the nature, extent, and location of matching material. A similarity percentage alone does not establish plagiarism or determine the editorial outcome.
Authors may be asked to provide original data, research records, source materials, or explanations where concerns arise.
Depending on the circumstances and seriousness of the issue, the journal may request revisions, reject the manuscript, suspend the review process, or initiate a research integrity investigation in accordance with relevant COPE guidance.
Research Ethics and Informed Consent
All research involving human participants, personal data, human biological materials, or other ethically sensitive subjects must comply with applicable institutional, national, and international ethical standards.
Where required, authors must obtain approval from an appropriate research ethics committee or institutional review board before conducting the research. The manuscript must identify the approving institution or committee and provide the relevant approval or reference number. Where formal ethical approval is not required or applicable, authors should provide an appropriate explanation in the manuscript.
Authors must obtain informed consent from research participants where appropriate. Consent procedures should clearly explain the purpose of the research, the use of collected information or materials, and any intended publication of identifiable information, quotations, images, recordings, or other personal data.
For research involving children, vulnerable individuals, sensitive personal information, or potentially distressing subjects, authors must demonstrate that appropriate ethical safeguards and consent procedures have been implemented.
For research involving interviews, surveys, observations, personal narratives, case studies, or other forms of human experience, authors must respect participants' privacy, dignity, autonomy, and confidentiality. Identifiable information should not be published without appropriate consent or another valid legal and ethical basis.
For research involving Indigenous communities, minority groups, or culturally sensitive knowledge and materials, authors should respect relevant community rights, cultural values, access conditions, and applicable consent requirements.
Authors must disclose any relevant ethical considerations and explain how potential risks to participants or other affected individuals have been addressed.
For theoretical, conceptual, philosophical, historical, and literature-based studies that do not involve human participants, personal data, or other ethically regulated research activities, formal ethical approval is generally not required. Authors may indicate that ethical approval and informed consent are not applicable, where appropriate.
The journal reserves the right to request ethical approval documents, consent statements, or other supporting information when necessary to assess compliance with research ethics requirements.
Data Availability and Research Transparency
The journal supports research transparency, reproducibility, and responsible data management. Authors are encouraged to make the data, materials, and resources supporting their research accessible wherever ethically, legally, and practically appropriate.
Where applicable, authors should include a Data Availability Statement in their manuscripts, indicating one of the following:
- Publicly Available: The data supporting the findings are available in a publicly accessible repository or other appropriate source, with relevant links or identifiers provided.
- Available Upon Request: The data are available from the corresponding author upon reasonable request, subject to applicable restrictions.
- Restricted Access: Access to the data is restricted due to privacy, confidentiality, ethical, legal, intellectual property, or other legitimate considerations. The relevant restrictions should be explained.
- Not Applicable: No new data were generated or analyzed, or data availability is not relevant to the nature of the research.
Authors must ensure that any shared data or research materials comply with applicable privacy and confidentiality requirements, copyright, intellectual property rights, informed consent conditions, and relevant ethical standards.
For research involving human participants, interviews, personal narratives, sensitive information, or other confidential materials, data sharing must not compromise participant privacy, confidentiality, or the rights and interests of individuals or communities.
For theoretical, conceptual, philosophical, and literature-based research, authors may indicate that data availability is not applicable where no original datasets were generated or analyzed.
Authors are expected to provide sufficient methodological information, references, and supporting materials to enable readers to understand and evaluate their research. Where necessary, the journal may request access to relevant supporting data, research materials, or analytical procedures for editorial assessment and verification.
The journal recognizes that responsible research transparency does not require the unrestricted disclosure of confidential, sensitive, or ethically protected information.
Conflicts of Interest
Authors must disclose any financial or non-financial relationships that could reasonably be perceived as influencing their research, interpretation, or publication.
Potential conflicts may include:
- Employment, consultancy, or professional relationships;
- Financial interests, grants, or commercial relationships;
- Personal or family relationships;
- Institutional affiliations or competing academic interests;
- Personal, professional, or intellectual disputes; and
- Other circumstances that may affect the impartiality of the research or editorial process.
Reviewers and editors must also disclose potential conflicts of interest and decline involvement when their impartiality may be compromised.
Editors must not handle manuscripts in which they have a direct personal, professional, institutional, or financial interest. Such manuscripts must be assigned to an independent editor who has no relevant conflict of interest.
If no conflicts of interest exist, authors should include the following statement:
"The authors declare no conflicts of interest."
Funding Disclosure
Authors must identify all sources of financial support for the research and publication, including relevant grant numbers, where applicable.
The role of the funding organization in the research design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, manuscript preparation, and decision to submit must be disclosed.
Authors must also disclose relevant institutional or commercial support that may have influenced the research.
If the research received no specific external funding, authors should include the following statement:
"This research received no external funding."
Use of Artificial Intelligence (AI)
Philosophy and Realistic Reflection recognizes that artificial intelligence (AI), including generative AI and large language models (LLMs), may support various aspects of academic research, language analysis, manuscript preparation, and scholarly communication.
The journal permits responsible use of AI-assisted tools where such use is transparent, appropriate to the research purpose, and consistent with academic integrity.
AI tools must not replace human scholarly judgment, independent critical analysis, or the responsibilities of authors, reviewers, and editors. Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, validity, and integrity of all submitted content, including material generated or modified with AI assistance.
The journal distinguishes between routine language assistance and substantive AI involvement in research or manuscript production. Disclosure requirements depend on the nature and extent of the use.
AI-assisted technologies may include, but are not limited to:
- Large language models and generative AI chatbots;
- AI-based writing, editing, translation, and paraphrasing tools;
- Automated transcription and speech recognition systems;
- AI-assisted corpus analysis, text classification, and linguistic annotation tools;
- Machine translation and multilingual language processing systems;
- AI-based data analysis, coding, and statistical assistance tools;
- Automated image, audio, video, and figure generation or modification tools; and
- Other AI systems used in research design, data collection, analysis, interpretation, or manuscript preparation.
The use of an AI tool must be evaluated according to its actual function in the research process rather than its product name or commercial category.
Permitted Uses of AI
Authors may use AI tools for appropriate and limited assistance, including:
- Correcting spelling, grammar, punctuation, and sentence structure;
- Improving language clarity, readability, and academic expression;
- Translating text for communication or manuscript preparation;
- Organizing notes, outlining sections, or improving manuscript structure;
- Assisting with coding, programming, or technical tasks;
- Supporting preliminary literature exploration or information organization;
- Assisting with transcription, translation, or preliminary annotation of linguistic materials; and
- Supporting data processing or analysis when the procedures are scientifically justified and adequately validated.
Such use is acceptable only when authors independently verify the outputs and retain responsibility for the scholarly content and conclusions.
The use of AI for routine spelling, grammar checking, and basic language correction, without generating or substantially rewriting scholarly content, does not normally require a separate disclosure statement.
However, substantial AI-assisted rewriting, content generation, translation of research materials, data processing, or analytical assistance must be disclosed in accordance.
Disclosure Requirements for Authors
Authors must disclose substantive use of AI tools during manuscript preparation or research.
Disclosure is required when AI tools have been used to:
- Generate, draft, or substantially rewrite sections of the manuscript;
- Develop or substantially modify research arguments, interpretations, or conclusions;
- Translate research materials, interview transcripts, questionnaires, or substantial portions of the manuscript;
- Collect, classify, annotate, transcribe, or process research data;
- Conduct or materially assist qualitative or quantitative analysis;
- Generate, modify, or substantially reconstruct figures, images, audio, video, or other research materials;
- Generate synthetic linguistic data, text, speech, or other research materials; or
- Perform other substantive tasks that influence the research design, methodology, findings, or presentation.
At submission, authors must declare whether AI tools were used in preparing or conducting the research. Where substantive use occurred, authors must provide the following information:
1. Tool identification: The name of the AI tool, system, or platform.
2. Version or model: The model name or version, where available.
3. Purpose of use: The specific task for which the tool was used.
4. Extent of use: The relevant stage or part of the research or manuscript affected.
5. Human verification: The steps taken by the authors to verify, correct, and validate the AI-assisted output.
Where relevant, authors should also provide the date or period of use, important settings or parameters, and the prompts or processing procedures necessary to understand or reproduce the work.
Disclosure should be included in the appropriate section of the manuscript:
- AI used primarily for writing assistance should be described in an Acknowledgments or AI Use Disclosure statement.
- AI used in research design, data collection, transcription, translation, annotation, analysis, or figure generation should be described in the Methods section or another appropriate methodological section.
- Where AI has been used in multiple stages, authors should provide a clear description of each substantive use.
Authors should also disclose relevant AI use in the journal's submission system and cover letter when requested.
Accuracy, Verification, and Academic Responsibility
Authors are responsible for carefully checking all AI-assisted content before submission and publication.
In particular, authors must:
- Verify factual claims, definitions, interpretations, and research-related statements.
- Check all references, citations, quotations, and bibliographic information against original sources.
- Ensure that AI-generated text does not reproduce copyrighted or unattributed material.
- Confirm that translations, transcripts, linguistic examples, and annotations accurately represent the original materials.
- Review AI-generated code, calculations, statistical outputs, and analytical results.
- Identify and correct hallucinations, fabricated references, inaccurate information, misleading interpretations, and inappropriate generalizations.
- Ensure that AI-generated content does not introduce cultural, linguistic, gender, or other forms of bias.
- Confirm that all research conclusions are supported by the underlying data and appropriate scholarly reasoning.
AI-generated references must never be accepted without independent verification. AI tools must not be treated as authoritative academic sources or substitutes for original scholarly publications.
Authors must not use AI to fabricate sources, quotations, participant responses, research findings, or supporting evidence.
AI-Generated Figures, Images, Audio, and Other Materials
Authors must disclose the use of AI tools to generate or substantially modify figures, images, illustrations, audio, video, or other materials included in a manuscript.
AI-generated or AI-modified materials must not be presented as authentic photographs, original recordings, experimental observations, or documentary evidence when they are not.
Authors must ensure that the use of such materials does not:
- Misrepresent research observations or evidence;
- Alter the meaning or integrity of original research materials;
- Violate copyright, licensing, privacy, or publicity rights;
- Misrepresent the identity or statements of research participants; or
- Create misleading visual, audio, or documentary evidence.
Where AI-generated materials are integral to the research methodology, authors must describe their production and validation in the Methods section.
The journal may request original files or supporting materials to assess the authenticity and integrity of submitted figures and other media.
Authorship and Acknowledgment of AI Tools
AI tools, chatbots, and other automated systems cannot be listed as authors or co-authors.
Authorship requires human accountability, intellectual contribution, approval of the final manuscript, and the ability to respond to questions concerning the integrity of the work. AI systems cannot fulfill these responsibilities.
Where AI tools have made a substantive contribution, authors must disclose the use of the tools in the appropriate manuscript section.
AI tools should not be listed as human authors or treated as responsible scholarly sources. Authors remain responsible for identifying and citing the original sources that support their arguments and findings.
Prohibited and Unacceptable Uses of AI
The following uses of AI are considered unacceptable:
- Using AI to fabricate, falsify, or manipulate research data, participant responses, quotations, references, or findings.
- Presenting AI-generated text, translations, annotations, or interpretations as verified research results without appropriate validation.
- Submitting AI-generated content that contains plagiarism, unattributed material, fabricated citations, or misleading information.
- Using AI to impersonate participants, reviewers, editors, or other individuals.
- Generating fictitious peer review reports, reviewer identities, research approvals, or institutional documentation.
- Using AI to conceal substantial content generation or to misrepresent the originality or intellectual contribution of a manuscript.
- Uploading confidential, restricted, or personally identifiable research data to AI services without appropriate authorization and safeguards.
- Using AI to manipulate images, recordings, transcripts, or other research evidence in a manner that misrepresents the original materials.
- Using AI-generated content to produce misleading or unsupported academic conclusions.
The journal evaluates suspected misuse on the basis of the nature, extent, context, and consequences of the conduct. Appropriate editorial or ethical action will be taken where necessary.
Use of AI by Reviewers
Reviewers must protect the confidentiality of all manuscripts and unpublished research materials received during peer review.
Reviewers must not upload submitted manuscripts, unpublished data, figures, supplementary materials, or identifiable manuscript content to publicly accessible or external AI systems where confidentiality and data protection cannot be assured, unless the journal and authors have provided explicit authorization.
Reviewers must not use AI tools to generate an entire peer review report or replace their independent scholarly assessment.
If AI assistance is permitted by the journal for a limited purpose, reviewers must:
- Disclose the use of AI to the handling editor;
- Use only systems that meet the journal's confidentiality and data protection requirements;
- Independently verify all AI-assisted comments and recommendations;
- Ensure that the review accurately reflects their own scholarly judgment; and
- Remain fully responsible for the content and recommendations of the review.
Reviewers must not use AI tools to identify authors of anonymized manuscripts, expose confidential information, or obtain an unfair advantage from unpublished research.
Use of AI by Editors and Editorial Staff
Editors and editorial staff must maintain the confidentiality, impartiality, and integrity of the editorial process.
Editors and editorial staff must not upload confidential manuscripts or unpublished research materials to AI systems where confidentiality cannot be assured, unless the journal and authors have explicitly authorized the use.
AI tools may be used for limited administrative or language-support purposes only when appropriate confidentiality and data protection safeguards are in place.
AI must not independently determine manuscript acceptance or rejection, replace substantive editorial judgment, or make final decisions concerning ethical misconduct.
Editors remain responsible for:
- Assessing manuscripts on their academic merit and relevance;
- Evaluating the appropriateness of AI use disclosed by authors;
- Requesting clarification or supporting information when necessary;
- Ensuring that AI-assisted editorial activities do not compromise confidentiality or fairness; and
- Making all final editorial decisions through appropriate human judgment.
Responsibilities of Editors
Editors are responsible for ensuring that editorial decisions are fair, independent, transparent, and based on the academic quality, originality, relevance, and contribution of submitted manuscripts.
Editors must:
- Evaluate manuscripts objectively and without discrimination.
- Ensure that submissions receive appropriate editorial assessment and peer review.
- Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and associated research materials.
- Identify and manage conflicts of interest.
- Avoid allowing commercial, financial, personal, or institutional interests to influence editorial decisions.
- Investigate credible concerns about research misconduct or publication ethics.
- Ensure that authors are treated fairly and given appropriate opportunities to respond to editorial concerns.
- Maintain accurate editorial records and document significant decisions.
Editors must not use unpublished information obtained through the editorial process for personal or professional advantage.
Where an editor has a conflict of interest, the manuscript must be assigned to an independent editor.
Responsibilities of Reviewers
Reviewers play an important role in maintaining the quality and integrity of the journal.
Reviewers are expected to:
- Accept review assignments only when they have relevant expertise and sufficient time.
- Provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based assessments.
- Maintain the confidentiality of manuscripts and unpublished research materials.
- Disclose potential conflicts of interest and decline assignments where impartiality may be compromised.
- Identify relevant published work that has not been appropriately cited.
- Report concerns about plagiarism, data integrity, ethical compliance, or inappropriate research practices to the editor.
- Avoid personal criticism, discriminatory language, or unsupported allegations.
- Submit their reviews within the agreed timeframe.
Reviewers must not use unpublished research information for personal benefit or disclose manuscript content to unauthorized individuals.
The journal's peer review procedures and reviewer expectations are described in its separate Peer Review Process and Reviewer Guidelines policies.
Research Misconduct and Allegations
The journal takes allegations of research misconduct seriously, whether they arise before or after publication.
Potential misconduct includes, but is not limited to:
- Plagiarism and inappropriate text recycling;
- Data fabrication or falsification;
- Duplicate or redundant publication;
- Improper authorship or undisclosed contributions;
- Undisclosed conflicts of interest;
- Manipulation of citations or peer review;
- Misrepresentation of research ethics approval or informed consent;
- Unauthorized use or disclosure of confidential research materials; and
- Inappropriate or undisclosed use of AI that compromises the integrity of the research or publication.
The journal takes all allegations of research and publication misconduct seriously, including plagiarism, data fabrication or falsification, duplicate publication, authorship disputes, and other forms of unethical research or publishing practices.
All allegations will be assessed carefully, impartially, and confidentially. The journal will follow the relevant procedures outlined in the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) guidelines and flowcharts, as appropriate to the nature of the case.
Where necessary, the journal may:
- Conduct a preliminary assessment of the available evidence and request explanations or supporting information from the authors or other relevant parties.
- Contact the authors' affiliated institutions, research integrity offices, or relevant funding bodies to request further investigation.
- Suspend the editorial or peer review process while serious concerns are being assessed.
- Take appropriate action based on the findings, including rejection of a manuscript, publication of a correction or an expression of concern, or retraction of a published article.
The journal will provide relevant parties with an opportunity to respond and will take appropriate measures to protect the confidentiality and rights of all parties involved. Decisions will be made based on the available evidence and the need to maintain the integrity of the scholarly record.
Complaints and Appeals
Authors may appeal an editorial decision when they believe that the decision resulted from a significant factual error, procedural irregularity, undisclosed conflict of interest, or inappropriate handling of their manuscript.
An appeal must include:
- The manuscript title and reference number;
- A clear explanation of the grounds for appeal;
- Specific concerns about the editorial decision or review process; and
- Relevant supporting information or documentation.
The journal will assess appeals independently where practicable. The original decision may be reconsidered when substantial grounds are established. Submission of an appeal does not guarantee a change in the editorial decision.
Complaints concerning editorial conduct, peer review, publication procedures, research integrity, or ethical matters may be submitted to contact@bilpub.com.
Complaints and appeals will be handled fairly, confidentially, and in accordance with relevant COPE guidance.
Corrections, Retractions, and Expressions of Concern
The journal is committed to maintaining the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record. Where errors, ethical concerns, or unreliable findings are identified after publication, the journal will assess the matter and take appropriate action. The journal will follow relevant COPE guidance when considering post-publication actions. Depending on the nature and seriousness of the issue, the journal may publish:
Correction
A correction may be issued when an error affects part of a published article but does not invalidate the overall findings or conclusions.
Retraction
A retraction may be issued when the findings are unreliable due to serious errors, research misconduct, plagiarism, unethical research practices, or other circumstances that undermine the integrity of the publication.
Expression of Concern
An expression of concern may be issued when substantial concerns have been raised but an investigation is ongoing or the available evidence is insufficient for a final determination.
All corrections, retractions, and expressions of concern will be clearly identified and linked to the original article wherever possible. The original publication record will be maintained transparently, with its publication status clearly indicated.
Copyright, Permissions, and Third-Party Materials
Authors are responsible for ensuring that they have the necessary rights and permissions to use third-party materials included in their manuscripts. This includes text, figures, tables, photographs, illustrations, recordings, datasets, and other copyrighted or restricted materials. Authors must provide appropriate acknowledgments and obtain permission where required.
The use of AI-generated or AI-modified materials does not remove the authors' responsibility to respect copyright, licensing, privacy, and other applicable rights.
The journal may request evidence of permission or authorization where necessary.
Confidentiality and Personal Information
The journal respects the confidentiality of unpublished manuscripts, research data, participant information, and personal information obtained during the editorial and peer review processes.
Editors, reviewers, and editorial staff must not disclose confidential information or use unpublished material for personal or professional benefit.
Personal information collected during submission, review, and publication will be handled in accordance with the journal's Privacy Policy and applicable data protection requirements.
Authors must ensure that personal or identifiable information included in their manuscripts has been appropriately authorized for publication.
Publisher Responsibilities and Editorial Independence
The publisher is responsible for providing the infrastructure, administrative support, and resources necessary for the journal's publication activities while respecting the academic independence of the editorial team.
Editorial decisions must be based on scholarly merit and must not be influenced by commercial considerations, publication fees, advertising, institutional relationships, or other inappropriate interests.
The publisher and editorial team share responsibility for maintaining transparent publishing practices, addressing ethical concerns, and protecting the integrity of the scholarly record. The publisher must not interfere with independent editorial decisions.
