The Debate in the Newspapers of the Young Enlightened of San Juan. An Ideological Struggle Through the Pen (1825–1861)

Authors

  • Ricardo Méndez Barozzi *

    Departamento de Ciencias Sociales, Universidad Nacional de Luján, Luján, Buenos Aires 6700, Argentina

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55121/cci.v2i1.606

Keywords:

Newspapers , Journalistic Debates , Liberal Ideas , Conservative Ideas , Argentina

Abstract

The written press in the Argentine province of San Juan is celebrating its bicentennial this year, having first appeared in 1825 when the printing press was introduced during the liberal government of Salvador María del Carril. This research project aims to investigate the influence of liberal ideology on the enlightened young members of the local elite. The study will cover the period from 1825 to the reissue of the newspaper El Zonda in 1861, just a few months before Domingo Faustino Sarmiento assumed the governorship. The ideological debate in the press is important for identifying the different factions within the provincial elite, as the aforementioned liberal sector was opposed by a more conservative faction that emphasized colonial traditions and the Roman Catholic religion. Likewise, the liberal and conservative sectors represented the Unitario and Federal parties respectively. During the first half of the 19th century, these parties engaged in a fierce struggle for political power throughout the Argentine Confederation. Liberal ideas were noticeably influenced by their counterparts in the United States and Europe. This ideology sought to modernize society and put an end to conservative ideas representing Spanish heritage, caudillos and backwardness. Therefore, this paper proposes to take a look at the print media in San Juan during the first half of the 19th century.

References

[1] Guerra, F., 1998. Public spaces in Latin America. Ambiguities and problems. 18th-19th centuries. Fondo De Cultura Economica: San Diego, California, USA. pp. 5–6, 116. (in Spanish)

[2] Méndez Barozzi, R., 2024a. School in nineteenth-century San Juan and the cultural influence of literary societies Procesos Históricos. 45, 53–65. (in Spanish)

[3] Lempérière A. Republic and advertising at the end of the Old Regime (New Spain). In: Guerra F, Lempérière A, editors. Public spaces in Latin America: ambiguities and problems. 18th–19th centuries. San Diego: Fondo de Cultura Económica; 1998. pp. 54-79.(in Spanish)

[4] De los Reyes, A., 2019. Review of Picco, Ernesto (2018). The Origins of the Press in the Argentine Provinces Folia Histórica del Nordeste. 36, 187–190. DOI: https://doi.org/10.30972/fhn.0364050 (in Spanish)

[5] Ruffini, M., 2019. Perspectives and approaches in a field under construction: historiography on the Patagonian press (1878–1955), Revista Electrónica de Fuentes y Archivos. 10, 211–227. (in Spanish)

[6] Palti, E., 2009. Revision and revolution. Ruptures and continuities in history and historiography. Historia Mexicana. 58(3), 1171–1198. (in Spanish)

[7] Szuchman, M., 2019. Fighting Words in an Angry Democracy: The Press in Revolutionary Buenos Aires, 1810–1820. Journalism History. 45(4), 353–380.

[8] Méndez Barozzi, R., 2024b. The May Charter on trial in its bicentennial: a look at early liberal ideology in Argentina. Historia Revista de la Carrera de Historia. 53, 9–30. (in Spanish)

[9] de Álvarez, A.G., 2023. Eureka! A reading of old newspapers. Revista de Literaturas Modernas. 53(1), 63–107. (in Spanish)

[10] Hudson, D., Historical memories of the province of Cuyo 1898. Juan Alsina: Buenos Aires, Argentina. pp. 67–207. (in Spanish)

[11] Gioja, J.L., 2015. Institutional and academic assessments. In: García, A.M.J., de López Aragón, S.M., Gnecco, M.J. (eds.). History of the Print Media in San Juan: Its Origins (1825–1852). FFHA-UNSJ: San Juan, Argentina. pp. 5–6. (in Spanish)

[12] García, A.M.J., de López Aragón, S.M., Gnecco, M.J., History of the Print Media in San Juan: Its Origins (1825–1852). FFHA 2015. FFHA-UNSJ: San Juan, Argentina. pp. 5–272. (in Spanish)

[13] Videla, H., 1972. History of San Juan. Patriotic Era, Volume III (1810-1836). Academia del Plata: Buenos Aires, Argentina. pp. 620–662. (in Spanish)

[14] Archivo General de la Nación, 2016a. Archives and collections from private sources. Salvador María del Carril Collection. (Collection). Special commissions and tributes. Volume III. Archivo General de la Nación: Buenos Aires, Argentina. (in Spanish).

[15] Méndez Barozzi, R., 2023. The early appearance of newspapers in nineteenth-century San Juan: a challenge for local society. ESPACIOS Digital. Revista de Humanidades y Ciencias Sociales de la UNPA. 2(2), 83–112. (in Spanish)

[16] Malberti, S., Puebla, F., 2015. The origins of the written press in San Juan under liberal influence. (1825–1827). In: García, A.M.J., de López Aragón, S.M., Gnecco, M.J. (eds.). History of the Print Media in San Juan: Its Origins (1825–1852). FFHA-UNSJ: San Juan, Argentina. pp. 65–117. (in Spanish)

[17] Fernández Pardo, C., 1969. Nazario Benavidez, Federalist Leader. Sudestada: Buenos Aires, Argentina. pp. 19. (in Spanish)

[18] Collado Macdur, G., Gálvez, R., 2017. Interdisciplinary-integrative analysis of a newspaper from San Juan, 19th century. In Proceedings of the XXI National Conference of Communication Researchers, San Juan, Argentina,14 December 2017; Available from: https://redcomunicacion.org/analisis-interdisciplinario-integrador-de-un-periodico-de-san-juan-siglo-xix/ (cited 30 May 2025). (in Spanish)

[19] Zinny, A., 1987. History of the governors of the Argentine provinces. Volume III. Hyspamérica: Buenos Aires, Argentina. (in Spanish)

[20] Archivo General de la Nación, 2016b. Archives and collections from private sources. Domingo Faustino Sarmiento Collection (Collection). Special commissions and tributes. Volumen III. Archivo General de la Nación: Buenos Aires, Argentina. (in Spanish)

[21] Fernández, G., Rueda Barboza, M.I., Gnecco, M.J., et al., 2015. The print media in San Juan under the influence of Facundo Quiroga in the province (1827–1835). In: García, A.M.J., de López Aragón, S.M., Gnecco, M.J. (eds.) History of the Print Media in San Juan: Its Origins (1825–1852). FFHA-UNSJ: San Juan, Argentina. pp. 119–214. (in Spanish)

[22] Videla, H., 1976. History of San Juan: Patriotic Era, Volume IV (1836-1862). Universidad Católica de Cuyo: San Juan, Argentina. (in Spanish)

[23] Sarmiento, D., 1874. Facundo, Civilization or Barbarism. Achette & Co: Paris, France. p. 168. (in Spanish)

[24] Sarmiento, D., 2003. Memories of the Province Biblioteca Virtual Universal: Buenos Aires, Argentina. pp. 49–119. (in Spanish)

[25] Cercós, M., Moreno, C., López Daneri, M., et al., 2015. The written press during the era of Nazario Benavides (1836–1852). In: García, A.M.J., de López Aragón, S.M., Gnecco, M.J. (eds.). History of the Print Media in San Juan: Its Origins (1825–1852). FFHA-UNSJ: San Juan, Argentina. pp. 217–272. (in Spanish)

[26] Mugnós de Escudero, M., 1939. San Juan (1810–1862). History of its Culture. In: Levene, R. (ed.). History of the Argentine Nation: from its origins to its definitive organization in 1862. Vol. X, Part Two El Ateneo: Buenos Aires, Argentina. pp. 205–221. (in Spanish)

Downloads

Issue

Vol. 2 No. 1 (June 2025)

Section

Articles