The Age of Machines: Anders on Work, Alienation and Promethean Gap

Authors

  • Federico Monaro *

    Department of Philosophy, Anthropology, Sociology and Aesthetic, University of Castilla-La Mancha, Albacete 02071, Spain

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.55121/prr.v2i2.705

Keywords:

Promethean Gap, Machines , Obsolescence of Man , Philosophy of Technology

Abstract

This article examines Günther Anders’s critical reflection on the human condition in technological modernity, focusing on the central concepts of the “obsolescence of man” and the Promethean Gap. The latter describes the widening disproportion between the productive power of machines and the limited cognitive, moral, and imaginative capacities of human beings. Anders argues that this imbalance generates alienation, disorientation, and even shame in relation to our own creations, as exemplified by the nuclear threat, which vastly exceeds our ethical preparedness to confront its consequences. Drawing on Marx and Heidegger, the article highlights how industrialization and automation have reshaped the sphere of labor, stripping it of creativity and meaning, and transforming human beings into passive supervisors of processes they can neither master nor fully comprehend. Alienation, once limited to the factory, increasingly permeates everyday life, producing a condition in which individuals experience themselves as inadequate when compared with the efficiency, durability, and autonomy of machines. Anders’s critique shows that technology is not a neutral instrument, but a social and political force that incorporates logics of domination and subordination, demanding adaptation at the cost of freedom and subjectivity. His work also anticipates contemporary debates on artificial intelligence, automation, and ecological collapse, underscoring the urgent need for new ethical and political frameworks capable of guiding human action in a technological age. By exposing the risks of a society that uncritically celebrates technical progress, Anders calls for renewed human agency rooted in responsibility, foresight, and resilience.

References

[1] Anders, G., 1980. The Obsolescence of Man 2. On the Destruction of Life in the Age of the Third Industrial Revolution. C. H. Beck: München, Germany. (in German)

[2] Anders, G., 1962. Theses for the Atomic Age. The Massachusetts Review. 3(3), 493–505.

[3] Latini, M., 2019. An Aesthetic of Overstatement. Jouvence: Milano, Italy. (in Italian)

[4] Heidegger, M., 2010. Being and Time. State University of New York Press: Albany, NY, USA.

[5] Latini, M., 2014. The World of the Day before Yesterday. The “Notes for Literature” by Günther Anders. In: Latini, M., Meccariello, A. (eds.) . Man and (His) End: Essays on Günther Anders. Asterios Editore: Trieste, Italy. pp. 183–200. (in Italian)

[6] Fuchs, C., 2017. Günther Anders’ Undiscovered Critical Theory of Technology in the Age of Big Data Capitalism. tripleC. 15(2), 582–611. DOI: https://doi.org/10.31269/triplec.v15i2.898

[7] Babich, B., 2025. Günther Anders’s “Promethean Shame”: Technological Ressentiment and Surveillance. The Harvard Review of Philosophy. 31, 75–97. DOI: https://doi.org/10.5840/harvardreview202522561

[8] Babich, B., 2022. Günther Anders’ Philosophy of Technology: From Phenomenology to Critical Theory. Bloomsbury Publishing: New York, NY, USA.

[9] Neto, M.M, 2024. Günther Anders Between Actualism and the Obsolescence of the Human Being. História da Historiografia: International Journal of Theory and History of Historiography. 17, 1–28. (in Portuguese)

[10] Grigenti, F., 2016. Existence and Machine: The German Philosophy in the Age of Machines (1870–1960). Springer: Aargau, Switzerland.

[11] Marx, K., 1909. Capital: A Critique of Political Economy, Volume I. Charles H. Kerr & Company: Chicago, IL, USA.

[12] Marx, K., 1988. Economic and Philosophic Manuscript of 1844. Prometheus Book: Amherst, NY, USA.

[13] Grigenti, F., 2021. Machines and Thought. Orthotes: Napoli-Salerno, Italy. (in Italian)

[14] Toscano, A., 2016. The Promethean Gap: Modernism, Machines, and the Obsolescence of Man. Modernism/Modernity. 23(3), 593–609.

[15] Anders, G., 1962. Burning Conscience: The Case of the Hiroshima Pilot Claude Eatherly Told in His Letters to Gunther Anders. Monthly Review Press: New York, USA.

[16] Anders, G., 2009. The Pathology of Freedom: An Essay on Non-Identification. Deleuze Studies. 3(2), 278–310. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3366/E1750224109000658

[17] Müller, C.J., 2016. Prometheanism: Technology, Digital Culture and Human Obsolescence. Rowman & Littlefield: London, UK.

[18] Anders, G., 1956. The Obsolescence of Man 1. About the Soul in the Age of the Second Industrial Revolution. C. H. Beck: München, Germany. (in German)

[19] Chaplin, C. (Director), 1936. Modern Times [Film]. Charlie Chaplin Productions: Los Angeles, CA, USA.

[20] Lang, F. (Director), 1927. Metropolis [Film]. Universum Film AG (UFA): Berlin, Germany.

[21] Babich, B., 2012. Martin Heidegger and Gunther Anders on Technology: On Ray Kurzweil, Fritz Lang, and Transhumanism. Journal of the Hannah Arendt Center for Politics and Humanities at Bard College. 2, 122–144.

[22] Hegel, G.F., 1807. Mastery and Servitude. In: Pinkard, T., Baur, M. (eds.). Phenomenology of Spirit, Vol. 3. Suhrkamp Verlag: Bamberg and Würzburg, Germany. (in German)

[23] Alvis, J.W., 2017. Transcendence of the Negative: Günther Anders' Apocalyptic Phenomenology. Religions. 8(4), 59. DOI: https://doi.org/10.3390/rel8040059

[24] Monaro, F., 2023. Pathological Existence and Freedom of Technology. The Drama of Freedom in Günther Anders’ Writings. Orbis Idearum. 11(1), 115–130.

[25] Anders, G., 2015. An Interpretation of A Posteriori. In: Clemente, L.F, Lolli, F. (eds.). Pathology of Freedom: Essay on Non-Identification. Orthotes: Napoli-Salerno, Italy. pp. 23–39. (in Italian)

[26] Esquirol, J.M., 2011. Contemporary Philosophers and Technique: From Ortega to Sloterdijk. Gedisa Editorial: Barcelona, Spain. (in Spanish)

[27] Schraube, E., 2005. Anders, Günther. In: Mitcham, C. (ed.). Encyclopedia of Science, Technology, and Ethics. Palgrave Macmillan: Farmington Hills, MI, USA. pp. 67–68.

[28] Stoszkowski, J., 2025. Günther Anders and Promethean Shame. Available from: https://johnstoszkowski.substack.com/p/gunther-anders-and-promethean-shame (cited 1 August 2025).

Downloads